Blog › Comparisons
ComparisonBest Data Removal Service: Ranked on Proof
Every service in this category claims a big broker number. Almost none of them show you a removal. This ranking scores the leading services on coverage by plan, evidence, re-checking, and billing, using their own published figures and the category's independent tests.
Switching from Incogni or DeleteMe? Sign up on an annual plan, send proof of an active subscription after you sign up, and we add 2 months, so your annual price covers 14 months. One benefit per customer, and you always get whichever single benefit is worth most. See how switching works.
The short answer
The best data removal service is the one that matches your deciding factor, because the category leaders each win a different thing. Incogni wins automated breadth: 420+ brokers on every plan at $95.88 USD a year. Optery wins visibility before you pay, with a free exposure report. DeleteMe wins human handling, with a named expert since 2011. Ghost Delete wins on proof per dollar in the US and Canada: every confirmed removal carries evidence, at CAD $79 or USD $55 a year. Ranked on claims, everyone wins. Ranked on evidence, the field narrows fast.
The ranking criteria that actually matter
Broker counts are the industry's favorite number and its least honest one, because a listed broker, an automated broker, and a broker who held your data are three different things. We rank on five criteria instead: automated coverage by plan, proof the customer can open, re-check and refile behavior when brokers relist, billing shape (monthly option, renewal price stated, guarantee length), and independent measurement where it exists. Every figure below is sourced to the provider's own published pages or to the named study, checked November 15, 2026.
Best data removal services compared
| Service | Best for | Price, one person | Automated coverage | Proof |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ghost Delete | Proof at the lowest full-service price, US and Canada | CAD $79 / USD $55 a year, monthly available | 52 Tier 1 first; 924 verified routes | Evidence attached to every confirmed removal |
| Incogni | Automated breadth, including Europe | $95.88 USD a year | 420+ on every plan | Status dashboard only |
| Optery | Free exposure report, screenshot reporting | Free tier; Core $39 USD a year | 380+ on Core, tiered above | Screenshots on Extended and up |
| DeleteMe | Human experts, custom requests on every plan | $129 USD a year, no monthly | About 90 on Standard of about 969 listed | Quarterly report |
| EasyOptOuts | Lowest price | $19.99 USD a year | About 200 | Status based |
| Kanary | High-risk and public-facing users | About $180 USD a year and up | Hundreds, tiered | Status based |
What independent testing says
Consumer Reports' August 2024 study is the category's only independent like-for-like test: 32 volunteers, 13 people-search sites, four months. Optery Ultimate removed 68 percent of tracked profiles, EasyOptOuts 65 percent, Kanary 34 percent, and DeleteMe 27 percent, while manual opt-outs removed about 70 percent. Incogni was not in that study; in a separate 2025 peer-reviewed study it removed 76.6 percent of records per participant in 30 days, the best of four services tested. Both studies are small and dated, and we present them with those limits. The pattern across both is consistent: services differ by a factor of two or more in measured results, and no paid service beat doing it yourself carefully. What a service buys you is the labor and the follow-through, which is why proof and re-checking matter more than the signup-day count.
Why we rank Ghost Delete first on proof, and where we lose
Full disclosure: this is our site, so weigh our placement accordingly and check the rivals' pages. Ghost Delete counts a removal only when the broker confirms it, attaches the evidence to the job, pairs the found and gone views, re-checks confirmed brokers, and refiles relistings automatically. We lose on automated breadth to Incogni, on track record to DeleteMe, on free discovery to Optery, and on price to EasyOptOuts. We win when the question is whether you can see, with your own eyes, that a listing came down, and what it cost: CAD $79 or USD $55 a year, a 60-day guarantee, and a free scan that shows your exposure before you pay. The four-way detail is at Ghost Delete vs Incogni vs DeleteMe vs Aura, and the worth-it analysis is at are data broker removal services worth it.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best data removal service?
There is no single best service for everyone, and any ranking that says otherwise is selling something. Incogni is best for automated breadth per dollar. Optery is best for a free exposure report and screenshot proof at its higher tiers. DeleteMe is best for human handling. Ghost Delete is best for US and Canadian customers who want proof attached to every confirmed removal at the lowest full-service price, CAD $79 or USD $55 a year.
How much does a data removal service cost?
Credible services run from $19.99 USD a year (EasyOptOuts, small automated list) to about $250 USD a year for top tiers with custom removals. The mainstream sits between $95 and $180 USD a year. Ghost Delete Individual is CAD $79 or USD $55 a year, Family CAD $199 or USD $139 a year for up to five people. Prices checked November 15, 2026.
Do data removal services actually work?
They file real requests and brokers do remove listings, but no service removes everything. In Consumer Reports' 2024 study, paid services removed between 27 and 68 percent of tracked profiles within four months, and careful manual opt-outs removed about 70 percent. The honest differences between services are coverage, follow-through on relistings, and whether you can see evidence of the result.
What should I look for in a data removal service?
Four things: automated coverage you can read by plan, not a headline list; proof of removal you can open yourself; a published re-check cycle, because brokers relist; and billing you can predict, including the renewal price and a real monthly option. A free scan that shows real listings before you pay is a fifth, and most services fail it.
See what is exposed before you pay
Ghost Delete starts with a free scan that shows your breach exposure. No card required.
Individual: $79 CAD a year or $9.99 a month in Canada, $55 USD a year or $6.99 a month in the US, plus tax. 60-day money-back guarantee.