Be a Ghost.  60-day money-back guarantee · US and Canada

The Ghost Delete Academy · Module 5, Lesson 20

When a report is wrong: disputes

Free lesson · About 12 minutes · Ends with the free scan

Errors are common, and they are fixable

You read your reports, as the last lesson taught, and something on the page is not yours.

It might be small: a balance you paid, still showing as owing. It might be serious: an account you never opened, at an address you have never lived. Either way, your first reaction matters less than your second one. The first is annoyance. The second should be a letter.

Credit reports are assembled from what companies report to the bureaus, and that pipeline makes mistakes. Files get merged. Payments get posted to the wrong account. A debt gets sold and reported twice, or reported again after it was settled. The system has a correction route built into it for exactly this reason. It is called a dispute, and this lesson walks through it in Canada and the United States.

One sorting decision comes first, before any paperwork. If the wrong item is an error, dispute it. If the wrong item is actually fraud, meaning someone opened or used an account as you, stop here and use Module 3's reporting steps first. A fraud case needs police and bank reporting and the steps on our report fraud page, not just a tidy correction. A dispute can follow once the fraud is on record.

Dispute with the bureau that holds the error

Go to the source of the file. The dispute belongs with the bureau whose report carries the error. If Equifax shows it, dispute with Equifax. If TransUnion shows it, dispute with TransUnion. If both show it, that is two disputes, one at each bureau. There is no central office that fixes all files at once.

Put it in writing where you can. The bureaus accept disputes online, by phone, and by mail, and the routes vary by bureau and by country. Written disputes, online with a saved confirmation or by letter you keep a copy of, leave a record you can point to later. A phone call leaves only your memory of it. Where you have the choice, choose the version you can file away.

Name the item and say why it is wrong. A good dispute is specific and short. Identify the account or entry exactly as it appears, state plainly what is wrong with it, and state what the correct information should be. "This account is not mine." "This balance was paid in full on this date." "This address is not an address I have ever lived at." Vague complaints get vague investigations.

Enclose copies of your proof, never originals. Send copies of the statement, the receipt, the letter, or the identification that supports your side. Keep your originals at home, always. Paper sent into a dispute process does not reliably come back, and you may need the same proof again for the company dispute described next.

What the bureau must do next

In the United States, typically within 30 days. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, a US bureau must investigate your dispute, typically within 30 days. The bureau contacts the company that reported the item, reviews your proof, and then tells you the result and corrects the file if the item cannot be verified or is shown to be wrong.

In Canada, the bureaus run their own investigation processes. Equifax Canada and TransUnion Canada each operate a dispute process, and you follow the steps that bureau sets out. Behind those processes sit your legal rights: provincial consumer law and the federal privacy law give you the right to have inaccurate information about you corrected. The timelines and forms are the bureau's. The underlying right to an accurate file is yours.

The bureau will ask the company. In both countries, expect the same middle step. The bureau does not usually decide alone. It takes your dispute to the company that furnished the information and asks that company to check its own records. That is why the next section exists, and why doing both halves gives your dispute its best chance.

Check the file again after. When the bureau replies, pull the report again and confirm the correction is actually there. A letter saying an item will be removed and a file that still shows it are two different things. Your six month reading rhythm from Lesson 19 will catch a quiet return, but a check right after the reply is better.

Dispute with the company that reported it, too

The company holds the original record. The bureau holds a copy of what the company sent. If the company's own records are wrong, the bureau's file can be corrected this month and re-reported wrong next month, because the source was never fixed. A dispute sent directly to the company attacks the error at its root.

Send the same clear account. Write to the company that reported the item, name the account, say what is wrong, and enclose the same copies of your proof. You do not need a different story for the company. You need the same facts, in the same order, with the same evidence.

Keep the two threads separate in your log. Note which bureau you wrote to and when, which company you wrote to and when, and what each one replied. Two threads, two sets of dates. When one side answers and the other does not, your log shows you exactly where the silence is.

Checklist: run a dispute properly, once

  1. Confirm the item is an error and not fraud. If it is fraud, use the Module 3 reporting steps first, then return here.
  2. Write down the item exactly as it appears: the company name, the account details shown, and the date of the report you pulled.
  3. Dispute with the bureau that holds the error, in writing where you can, naming the item, why it is wrong, and what the correct information is.
  4. Enclose copies of your proof. Never send originals.
  5. Send the same dispute, with the same proof copies, to the company that reported the item.
  6. Log every letter, date, confirmation, and reply in your removal log. The habit from Lesson 8 was built for paperwork exactly like this.
  7. When the bureau replies, pull your report again and confirm the correction appears on the file itself.
  8. Run the free scan while the paperwork moves. Disputes fix the credit file. The scan watches the breach side, which the bureaus do not cover.

If the bureau will not fix it

Sometimes a bureau investigates, the company insists its record is right, and the error stays. That is not the end of the road. It is the point where the complaint moves up a level.

In Canada, complain above the bureau. If a Canadian bureau will not correct information you believe is inaccurate, you can complain to the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, or to your provincial consumer protection office. Which office fits depends on whether your complaint is about privacy and accuracy of your personal information, or about consumer reporting practices in your province. Both routes exist so that a bureau's answer is not the final word.

In the United States, complain to the CFPB. If a US bureau will not fix an error, you can complain to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. The CFPB takes consumer complaints about credit reporting, passes them to the company, and tracks the response. Companies tend to read a complaint with a regulator attached more carefully than a second letter from the same customer.

Keep your paper either way. A complaint to a commissioner, a protection office, or the CFPB rests on the record you built: the original report, your dispute, your proof, the replies. This is the practical reason for the log. The person with the dated file does not have to reconstruct the story from memory a year later.

The honest ending: slow, paper heavy, worth doing once properly

No part of this lesson should be oversold. Disputes are slow. They are paper heavy. They involve waiting for investigations you cannot watch, and replies that arrive in the language of forms. People put them off for months for understandable reasons, and live with a worse file and worse offers in the meantime.

They also work often enough to be worth doing properly once. A paid debt shown as owing gets corrected. A stranger's account gets removed from your name. An address that was never yours comes off the file. Each fix improves every decision that gets made from that report afterward.

Do it once, do it in writing, keep everything, and then let the twice a year rhythm from Lesson 19 watch for the next error. That is the whole system. It is not fast, and it is yours.

Nothing in this lesson is legal or financial advice. It is a plain description of the dispute and complaint routes, so you can use them or take your situation to a qualified professional. The full Academy index is at the Free Academy.

Next lesson: Relisting: why listings come back.

Be a Ghost.

Lesson sources: Fair Credit Reporting Act investigation duties for US bureaus, typically within 30 days, and Consumer Financial Protection Bureau guidance on credit reporting complaints. Equifax Canada and TransUnion Canada dispute processes, with correction rights under Canadian federal privacy law and provincial consumer law, and complaint routes to the Privacy Commissioner of Canada and provincial consumer protection offices. This lesson is general information only, not legal or financial advice.